Mp3s vs WAVs – know your file formats!
When I hear someone reminiscing about MP’s and magazines I instinctively assume they are talking about music. When of course they go beyond mp4’s (mp5’s, mp6’s, mp7’s, etc.) it usually dawns on me that they are talking about hunting. If you aren’t part of the music world, you may have never heard of aiff, wav, aac, ogg, or flac files. You may at least recognize mp3 files but if someone told you that “mp3” stands for “m-peg three” you would probably smile and nod politely. Music files are everything to musicians and the difference between an mp3 and a wav may not mean much to the everyday mind, but to people who create music it is SUPER essential.
Mp3s vs WAVs

Unfortunately, while there are many blogs that go into detail about the difference between an mp3 and wav there aren’t too many that present concrete examples and invite listeners to hear for themselves. Challenge: Think you can hear the difference? Put your ears to the test! Below this paragraph you will find two links; one is a link to an mp3 and the other is a link to a wav file. Think you know which is which? Give it a whirl! And no cheating and skipping to the end where I reveal the answer.
File A: https://soundcloud.com/user-550028505/file-a/s-JuOk5BNu01K
File B: https://soundcloud.com/user-550028505/file-b-1/s-LIzUkdJerHg
If you aren’t an audiophile you may be wondering why I would ask you to listen to the same file twice. Though to the untrained ear they may sound identical there are some key differences between them. To learn more about the important differences between mp3’s and wav files read more below.
Important differences – Mp3s vs WAVs
Mp3 files are small.
We all know that size is relative. Afterall my dad grew up in an era where 10 mb was considered a bottomless pit. Of course, in the modern music world, 10 mb might as well be equivalent to ten itsy-bitsy particles of dust. In other words, it is virtually nothing. To give you an idea of how small a one minute mp3 file can be, I will tell you that one of the files you heard is about a fifth the size of 10 mb (why are you making us do math in a music blog)? To be exact, it is 1,963,360 bytes or roughly 2 mb in size. Though 1,963,360 may seem like a big number, when used to quantify bytes it is pretty tiny. Think of it this way: one megabyte is microscopic, and one byte is really microscopic. Okay, so how about wav files. How big are those?
Wav files are massive.
Though you may not have noticed a difference between the two files, what if I told you that one of the files is roughly 9 TIMES the size of the other? So, multiply 1,963,360 by 9 (no thankyou) and what do you get? Almost 18 MILLION. The wav version of those two files, is 17,382,362 bytes or 17.9 megabytes in comparison (to 2 mb). And to most people, it sounds EXACTLY the same as the mp3. So, if the two are virtually the same and one takes up significantly less data than the other, would it make sense to stop using wav’s altogether? Not necessarily. Here’s why.
Mp3 files are very poor in quality compared to wavs.
I can’t stand when someone fills up a half empty bottle of soap with water –as if that magically turns it into a full bottle of soap. Okay, it’s a full bottle but when you go to pump it you are still pumping out 50% water. Just as frugalists think replacing empty bottles with water is an efficient alternative to replacing the bottles themselves, lots of musicians think exporting projects as mp3’s is a no-brain solution to preserving their sessions while saving data. So instead of picturing someone filling up a half-empty bottle of soap with water, now imagine someone filling up a bottle that is only about a tenth full with 9/10 of water. Mp3 files are lossy, which means they do not feature the full frequency spectrum as their wav counterparts. They filter out really low and really high frequencies. They are in essence, “watered down.” They may be just as loud as wavs but like the diluted soap bottles, they don’t contain the “full product.”
Wav files are a standard for distributing.
If you are intending to release music or finished products, it is essential that you bounce sessions as wavs. If you want to upload files to SoundCloud, you are best off exporting files as wavs because much of the music distribution platforms already compress files to begin with, which means if you submit a lossy mp3 file to a platform which adds more compression, you will be losing much more of the quality than if you upload a wav file which contains no compression from the start.
Mp3 files are a standard for demo and broadcast.
If you want to show a client a sample of an idea you are having it might make sense to bounce the session off as an mp3 especially if you are transferring files through email. When you present a file to a big-wig agent as a finished-product you should present it as a wav. When such files are broadcast over the radio, they are converted and compressed into mp3’s. It makes sense given the massive amount of data that it would take to broadcast wav files in their purest form.
Mp3s vs WAVs – The Bottom Line
Be smart, and know your files! Mp3 files are much smaller than wav files. They sound virtually the same to the untrained ear, but they are much lesser in quality. Wav files are standard for distributing, submitting and uploading, because they are usually compressed and converted to suit the standard of whatever platform they are being broadcast from. It is important to understand that all files have their pros and cons and there is no one-size-fits all answer as to which is best. As a bonus for sticking to the end, I have attached a link to a very uncommon file that is seldom, if at all, discussed in the music business: an mp2 file.
Mp2 file: https://soundcloud.com/user-550028505/file-c/s-9ONl1bhi5mR
WOAH! To learn about uncommon files keep checking into Composer’s Toolbox. I just might post another article about the lesser known files of music (with interactive links to examples). And check out the many fine articles by Dan List and other wonderful contributors. And now for the moment you’ve all been waiting for…The answer to the question “which file (A or B) is the wav and which is the mp3?” Drumroll please….File A is the wav and file B is the mp3. Awesome! I bet you’ll sleep well tonight. 🙂
David Pennise

Composer, French Hornist
B.S. Music Theory and Composition;
MFA Candidate
Senior Composition Instructor, Composition Online
Masterclasses: Mini Master Class Monthly | Mini Master Class Bi-Monthly (20% Discount)
Website: https://dpennise4.wixsite.com/dapmusic
SoundCloud: https://soundcloud.com/user-550028505
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/dapennise/
